Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: You guys won't like this

February 05, 2022 05:11AM
Quote

However, even if the guy who was arrested was not the aggressor his response has to be "reasonable" in that he must have a reasonable belief the force he displays is necessary to protect himself from some imminent violence. Moreover, and this is critical, whatever force he uses must be proportionate to the force used against him.

This is only partially correct. The use of force in response must be proportionate to the threat against him, not the initial use of force.

Of course we don't know any details at this point, but as an example.

If the attacker and the victim are both 6' 190# and the attacker pushes the victim and turns to walk away, it would not be proportionate for the victim to go punch that attacker in the face.

If the attacker is 6'4" 250# and the victim is 5'10" and 175# and the attacker pushes the victim and keeps coming at him, punching the attacker in the face is certainly proportionate to the threat.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 02/05/2022 05:36AM by CeeZar.
SubjectAuthorViewsPosted

  Uh-Oh...Looks Like 9'er Fan Caught A Beat Down

ramBRO1990February 02, 2022 06:45PM

  Re: Uh-Oh...Looks Like 9'er Fan Caught A Beat Down

Ram_Ruler416February 02, 2022 07:02PM

  After the SF vs Dallas game, I saw video Cowboys fans fighting each other

ramzilla419February 02, 2022 07:45PM

  Something is wrong in our society....

JamesJM421February 02, 2022 08:20PM

  Re: Something is wrong in our society....

waterfield403February 02, 2022 08:51PM

  Re: Something is wrong in our society....

Ramkind400February 02, 2022 09:00PM

  Yeah, I think most would agree with that...

JamesJM344February 02, 2022 09:57PM

  VERY fragile egos out there.

Ramgator484February 03, 2022 02:48AM

  Glorification of Crime and Being a Victim justifies actions

Rams_81339February 03, 2022 06:48AM

  Re: Something is wrong in our society....

bigjimram21548February 03, 2022 01:49AM

  While I agree...

Atlantic Ram344February 03, 2022 02:58AM

  Lots of assumptions being made.

CeeZar425February 03, 2022 03:27AM

  Re: Lots of assumptions being made.

Ramboni361February 03, 2022 04:33AM

  I saw a Rams fan at the Tampa game who was LIT! He spent more time...

Ramgator399February 03, 2022 03:09AM

  Re: Uh-Oh...Looks Like 9'er Fan Caught A Beat Down

Tony Romas521February 03, 2022 03:16AM

  Video of the vicious beating found...

JYB525February 03, 2022 04:16AM

  Not surprised...

Ramsdude362February 03, 2022 04:38AM

  Re: Not surprised...

MamaRAMa364February 03, 2022 05:04AM

  Re: Not surprised...

Ramstien335February 03, 2022 05:13AM

  Re: Not surprised...

sfbayram435February 04, 2022 01:52PM

  Looks like the Niner fan started it.

NewMexicoRam401February 04, 2022 04:36AM

  Re: Looks like the Niner fan started it.

Ramsdude392February 04, 2022 05:14AM

  Re: Looks like the Niner fan started it.

ramithard360February 04, 2022 05:19AM

  Then he deserved being put in a coma

waterfield476February 04, 2022 12:20PM

  obviously

CeeZar486February 04, 2022 12:58PM

  Re: obviously

GlacieRam325February 04, 2022 01:39PM

  game had been going for about 45 minutes

21Dog306February 04, 2022 05:21AM

  I keep reading he was found around 4pm local time....

RAMbler324February 04, 2022 06:08AM

  thanks for the correction

21Dog307February 04, 2022 06:11AM

  Report: Suspect Arrested In SoFi Stadium Beating

ramBRO478February 04, 2022 06:01AM

  Updated Info

ramBRO472February 04, 2022 09:15AM

  Re: Updated Info

oldschoolramfan382February 04, 2022 09:58AM

  DA should not press charges on this one

merlin375February 04, 2022 10:10AM

  Re: DA should not press charges on this one

Rampage2k332February 04, 2022 11:10AM

  Re: DA should not press charges on this one

21Dog566February 04, 2022 11:18AM

  Re: DA should not press charges on this one

Rampage2k402February 04, 2022 11:29AM

  You guys won't like this

waterfield359February 04, 2022 04:53PM

  Re: You guys won't like this

RamsfanRobLA599February 04, 2022 06:55PM

  Re: You guys won't like this

CeeZar788February 05, 2022 05:11AM

  Re: You guys won't like this

waterfield321February 05, 2022 09:18AM

  Re: DA should not press charges on this one

napoli344February 04, 2022 06:45PM

  Re: Updated Info: Both might be guilty but turn the cheek

Anonymous User347February 05, 2022 01:30PM

  Reminds me of when I was at Soldier Field in 1977

NewMexicoRam399February 05, 2022 03:01PM

  Update: Man Charged With Felony Battery In SoFi Stadium Altercation; Victim Out Of Coma

ramBRO734March 10, 2022 09:47AM

  Re: Update: Man Charged With Felony Battery In SoFi Stadium Altercation; Victim Out Of Coma

SoCalRAMatic413March 10, 2022 09:58AM

  Re: Update: Man Charged With Felony Battery In SoFi Stadium Altercation; Victim Out Of Coma

Ramstien526March 10, 2022 01:05PM

  Re: Update: Man Charged With Felony Battery In SoFi Stadium Altercation; Victim Out Of Coma

Golden Ram346March 11, 2022 04:07AM