Well, if you're just going to create your own definitions so that your arguments work, there isn't much to talk about.
You specifically said more than once that he has never been elite. Which isn't true. Your version elite is just that, your version. Not the actual definition. And I don't think it's particularly "honest" to downplay what he's done and/or disregard the circumstances.
But, it is telling that you hold Stafford responsible for the Lions not winning playoff games. You seem to have some kind of grudge against him. Because the sentiment that I get from Rams fans has pretty consistently been that he is a talented QB who is going from a poor situation to a good situation and that warrants optimism and high expectations. I have not seen many who have been arguing that he is and has always been elite.
