Quote
zn
Quote
Rams43
Well, you’re definitely entitled to your opinion, zn, but we certainly see this one differently.
We’ve seen 2 years of both Shanny and McVay and there’s no comparison when considering their respective HC skills beyond the Offensive X’s and O’s.
No what we've seen is a good head coach who inherited a team and inherited a good GM who knew the team already, v. a good head coach who had to start over, did not have the players to start with, and has a GM who is as new and green as he is, and then suffered key injuries on top of it.
This is similar in some ways to the Bulger debates from 2007. People would say, Bulger is not playing well, what''s his problem. And others, including me, would point out the massive and unprecedented extent of OL injuries and stress how it's rare for a qb to play well with a bad OL like that (plus how playing with injured ribs has a direct effect on a qb's accuracy and velocity). Some people just absolutely could not hear that.
To me if one doesn't account for the context one ends up talking in a vacuum.
....
...
I suggest that we revisit this topic about 2 more years into their respective careers, zn.
That will be a sufficient time to evaluate each HC, don’t you think?
I mean, I’m already convinced, but you seem to need more evidence.
