Quote
Rams_81
and was 18-4 in his first 22 games.

We are of course discussing #2 caliber qbs. Not qbs who were #1 caliber starters who just spent time on the bench before starting.

That was directly specified.

Otherwise you end up saying that Warner, Green (in 2000), and Bulger were all #2 caliber qbs, which is of course nonsense.

Keenum is a #2 type. That's clear. So you want to compare him to other #2 types. Or you just end up with gibberish. Distinctions like that matter.

.