and you're nitpicking games to try and support a theory ""I believe we saw the same thing with Faulk years ago when he went from a 4.0 ypc back to a 5.5 ypc back."

And in my opinion, your theory is not valid. Gurley averaged 4.8 in 2015 and 4.7 in 2017. So, the comparison, in my opinion, does not hold. McVay didn't come along and do what you think happened to Faulk to Gurley.

BTW, that theory was off, too, but that's another story in my opinion.