Flyers and Islanders. Neither one of us were Hockey fans but we wore that game out! I remember us sitting on the Living Room floor, eating pizza and playing for 1-2 hours at a time. I bought one for my boys about 18 years ago and it was cheap garbage. They played with it far less than what me and my Brother used to do and it still fell apart in just a few months.
I don't know why but I always liked the old school table top / Home versions better than the ones you'd find in Arcades. Can't explain why. Just seemed like more fun. Maybe because you didn't have to toss four quarters or tokens into it??