I'm not sure exactly what the disagreement is. I agree with you on points 1 and 2 but neither of those have to do with a charge that he's
always injured which is what you said.
I showed that facts indicate he played in 15 games last year. It seems tough to always be injured and do that. Can we agree that he has durability concerns but saying he's "always injured" is hyperbole?
And I don't see anyone on the board complaining about limited production. Every sentiment seems to be about him staying healthy. There is a health aspect there with him; I'm simply saying that you're overstating it. And you seem to be implying that 600 yards production is bad. That's quite overstated too IMO given that he was coming off the bench in the 2nd half.
