Quote
Rampage2K-
Quote
moklerman
Quote
Rampage2K-
Quote
moklerman
Quote
stlrams13
I've watched the guy play
Unlike some on here I am lucky enough to have nfl Sunday ticket and game pass
I'm a football junkie
And my comment is a critique of the post.
Hence how about some other ideas?
I'm not against replacing Goff or bringing in competition but if we're going to replace him it needs to be an improvement.
Like a Watson or a high draft pick
Well, the sad reality is Minshew, on a HORRIBLE team, actually put up better numbers than Goff. That's why we're in this mess and likely why McVay is frustrated, if not done with, Goff.
you do realize most of those numbers were straight garbage time numbers from being down late in so many games right?
you have to put things in proper context sometimes to get a clearer picture....
"stats are for losers, final scores are for winners"- Bill Belichick
[
twitter.com]
Minshew was 1-8 this year as a starter btw
Minshew only threw 24 passes when trailing with less than 4 minutes to go, so no, they weren't all garbage time stats. He did throw most of his passes when the Jaguars were trailing, which only furthers the point that he was playing QB on a bad team. Out of all of his passes, he only attempted a total of 4 passes when the Jaguars were leading. Goff had 211 attempts when leading by comparison.
But, if all passes thrown when trailing are garbage time and easier to accumulate, why was Menshew's rating 99.1 with 16TD/4INT and Goff's 86.6 with 9TD/6INT?
[
twitter.com]
yeah, Minshew is better than Goff..you win
Statistically, he is. Out of these two QB's, one produced more on a bad team while one produced less on a good team.
I'd MUCH rather pay Menshew peanuts and have flexibility in other areas than pay Goff top dollar to produce less than Menshew. What fool wouldn't?