I just watched American Underdog and it was a great movie. Near the end I had a thought, if Rams / us had to pick one of these, in their prime and healthy, to be their starting QB, who do you take?

I'm a Kurt Warner fan so I'd pick him. I'm also a fan of Stafford and supported the trade for him 100% since day one because I knew how great he was in a dog-team like Detroit. The reason I'd pick Warner is because I saw him play during the Greatest Show on Turf. My goodness the passes he made in such tight coverage.

I have not taken a look at their stats career wise, I'm just going off of my gut feel for who I thought is/was a better QB when healthy.

I also hope that everyone understands I'm not trying to be divisive. Maybe this year Stafford surpasses the Greatest Show on Turf and I'd love it!