I felt similar to you about the Atwell pick. I felt really let down when they didn't draft a center and I chalked it up to McVay's penchant for being tricksey and cute. I can't see that little guy lasting long or making much of an impact.
I'm no OLine expert but our current cast of characters doesn't overly impress me. Like most everyone else I think they need OLine help. OTOH, I give McVay a lot of credit and tell myself to give him the benefit of the doubt because he certainly has earned it. I'm wrong about football stuff more often than he is. I just haven't been able to convince myself that it was a good 2nd round pick.
Thank you for the write up. It's always a pleasure to read you and Dead.