interesting, and challenging

immediately I was trying to come up how to handle what is a hit, what is success.
Using a 3 year threshold, and grabbing the list for the Rams from 2015:

10 1 10 Todd Gurley RB Georgia
57 2 25 Rob Havenstein OT Wisconsin
72 3 8 Jamon Brown OT Louisville
89 3 25 Sean Mannion QB Oregon St.

Guess you have to make the selection then, and grade it now.
I would have guessed yes on all but Brown. He was not a reach, but just an unknown, and would be easier to grade a miss
Fisher / Snead snagging Mannion? Immensely smart, all time leader in passing stats for Pac-12. How do you grade a backup QB? Based on stats, and some familiarity with him cuz of the Pac-12, I'd say hit.

Easily for a hit: Just being on a roster makes you a win after 3 years? Isn't there some need to weight the top 25 with a need to lead the league statistical in some category?

Needless to say, I'd be curious to play along.