Should that be a minimum in determining a Hit? ....But then what do you do with a backup QB -- Mannion
Also, should where the player was picked factor in? Should it be a tougher standard for someone picked in the Top 10 vs. the 3rd round?
Gurley and Brown are both starters....if their draft positions were reversed would it change their status? Gurley in the 3rd would obviously be a home run, but Brown's level of play picked at #10 would be characterized as a disappointment.
Right now I'd say Brown would be a hit, but if he were to lose his starting job this year, then it would be a miss. 4 years is a better time period to make a judgement.