Frankly, I'm still a little on the fence.
I like Goff and think he thrives under a different dynamic and I wouldn't have given up this early for several reasons: I think he is a top 10-12 QB in the Matty Ice mold, he has experience winning and that extension.
But I have always liked Matt Stafford, but I tend to like gunslingers: Fouts, Favre, Warner......I think Stafford is in that mold and that is the type of QB I enjoy
The rub for me: It's a team game, the salary cap situation is absurd IMO.....will hurt depth on defense and the OL, which was already thin.
I also have doubts about McVay, which are very unpopular on the board. I don't know if it's youth or what, but pattern seems to be developing with him.......and I think whatever upset him about Goff is partly his fault.