Brady, Manning, or Brees over Rodgers.
All 4 great but Rodgers be #1
I believe the intangibles are fabricated based on circumstances and Rodgers has the best arm, best accuracy, best mobility.
I rank them
1) Rodgers
2) Manning
3) Brady
4) Brees
But all 4 are great ones for sure.
Even though the Patriots always win when Brady misses, they don't look at good or win quite as much and I know he is a great player, but The bottom falls out when Rodgers misses any snaps even for the Packers. That is grading on the curve. I think all 3 of these would win the same number of superbowls with the Patriots, Rodgers, Brees, Manning.
I rank Brees at the bottom just because of his size and how that impacts his vision at times, but he is more mobile than Manning and Brady.
Manning, I rank over Brady, because I believe his he just more polished with QB skills overall.
While winning is a criteria, I think it is overplayed as you can't control the other 21 starting players, especially the other 11 on defense.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 01/23/2019 06:19AM by Rams_81.
