Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

September 30, 2024 07:19PM
Poll
Was McVay premature in trading away Goff to acquire Stafford?
Only registered users are allowed to vote for this poll.
63 votes were received.
Nope. A SB is a SB even if Rams only get one from this trade.51
 
81%
Yep. It was an ‘instant gratification’ move that has helped Lions far more than Rams.12
 
19%



Tactically it was a good move because Rams immediately won a SB with Stafford.

But strategically? I think it was a mistake.

Lions got all those premium picks plus Goff, handled properly, is looking like an All Pro just entering his prime.

As McVay has said himself, he can be impetuous. And in this instance I think it’s bitten him in the butt Big Time.

The Ernest Jones trade might be another example of McVay’s impetuosity.

Your thoughts and comments welcome.
SubjectAuthorViewsPosted

  Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

Rams43963September 30, 2024 07:19PM

  Re: Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

BumRap156September 30, 2024 07:23PM

  Delete

OhioRamsFan187September 30, 2024 07:37PM

  Then you missed the point.

BumRap216September 30, 2024 07:53PM

  Re: Then you missed the point.

OhioRamsFan227September 30, 2024 07:56PM

  So you're saying Stafford wasn't as good as he seemed in 21?

OhioRamsFan222September 30, 2024 08:01PM

  Re: So you're saying Stafford wasn't as good as he seemed in 21?

BumRap196September 30, 2024 08:31PM

  Re: Delete

AlbaNY_Ram102October 01, 2024 04:45AM

  Some truth on Goff

waterfield203September 30, 2024 08:24PM

  100%

OhioRamsFan134September 30, 2024 08:25PM

  Re: Some truth on Goff - hre's more to consider

mtramfan242September 30, 2024 09:33PM

  Hit Goff and he turns into a turtle

joram136October 01, 2024 02:02AM

  Re: Some truth on Goff - hre's more to consider

Suh-weet!90October 05, 2024 03:14PM

  Re: Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

Great Bordeni105October 01, 2024 12:20AM

  Goff isn't the first QB to find success with another team

DeaconDan194October 01, 2024 01:44AM

  Re: Goff isn't the first QB to find success with another team

Old Goat80October 01, 2024 03:42AM

  Re: Goff isn't the first QB to find success with another team

Rams4393October 01, 2024 04:14AM

  Re: Goff isn't the first QB to find success with another team

Old Goat181October 01, 2024 06:24AM

  We is talking past each other, OG…

Rams43103October 01, 2024 07:40AM

  Re: We is talking past each other, OG…

Classicalwit96October 01, 2024 07:52AM

  Re: We is talking past each other, OG…

Old Goat103October 01, 2024 09:07AM

  Re: We is talking past each other, OG…

21Dog169October 01, 2024 10:50AM

  Stafford and Goff both went to a Super Bowl with McVay

DeaconDan183October 01, 2024 12:14PM

  They had done it before.

waterfield173October 01, 2024 06:26AM

  Re: They had done it before.

DeaconDan109October 01, 2024 12:17PM

  Re: They had done it before.

waterfield84October 01, 2024 12:33PM

  Re: Goff isn't the first QB to find success with another team

GroundPounder192October 03, 2024 09:39AM

  Re: Goff isn't the first QB to find success with another team

DeaconDan164October 05, 2024 04:00PM

  What about the 1970's Rams?

NewMexicoRam87October 04, 2024 04:26AM

  worst QBS EVER

ferragamo7980October 04, 2024 10:58AM

  Not sure about worst ever lol

Ramsdude110October 04, 2024 12:31PM

  I don't think so..

sstrams215October 01, 2024 02:12AM

  That SB loss was on McVay more than Goff based on what a former Patriots LB said

LesBaker160October 03, 2024 10:44AM

  Re: Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

303089October 01, 2024 02:22AM

  Some interesting comments, but I think one factor has largely been overlooked…

Rams43234October 01, 2024 02:39AM

  Re: Some interesting comments, but I think one factor has largely been overlooked…

Suh-weet!105October 01, 2024 06:51PM

  they both ended up in great situations (nm)

LMU9392October 01, 2024 03:47AM

  of course....good for both teams nm

21Dog87October 01, 2024 04:48AM

  Re: Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

Classicalwit189October 01, 2024 04:14AM

  Re: Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

Ramsdude202October 01, 2024 09:13AM

  If ifs and buts were candy and nuts we'd all have a merry christmas

promomasterj197October 01, 2024 09:27AM

  No but...

Speed_Kills111October 02, 2024 02:53AM

  trade was based on a two-year decline, not being impetuous

LMU9390October 02, 2024 04:01AM

  Don’t you find it interesting that Goff was in decline under McVay and he’s now elite under Campbell?

Rams43138October 02, 2024 04:12AM

  Re: Don’t you find it interesting that Goff was in decline under McVay and he’s now elite under Campbell?

den-the-coach127October 02, 2024 04:23AM

  Goff is not an elite player

OhioRamsFan176October 02, 2024 08:37AM

  Let's hear you make the case that he isn't even close

LesBaker160October 02, 2024 11:15AM

  This is my contention, I guess…

Rams43198October 02, 2024 05:41AM

  Re: This is my contention, I guess…

Suh-weet!142October 05, 2024 03:12PM

  Goffs performance looked great

OzRam141October 02, 2024 11:31AM

  Re: Goffs performance looked great

Suh-weet!179October 02, 2024 12:54PM

  Toothsayer weighs in…

Rams43181October 03, 2024 07:17AM

  Re: No Way Is Goff Successful in LA

RamsFanSince69185October 03, 2024 06:58PM

  Re: Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

Great Bordeni93October 04, 2024 02:48AM

  43, you sound like you're turning into me

Coy Bacon125October 04, 2024 08:08AM

  Re: 43, you sound like you're turning into me

Rams43104October 04, 2024 08:20AM

  Re: 43, you sound like you're turning into me

Suh-weet!97October 05, 2024 03:10PM

  Re: 43, you sound like you're turning into me

303093October 05, 2024 04:37PM

  Re: 43, you sound like you're turning into me

Coy Bacon82October 05, 2024 05:02PM

  So, so , so, much traffic on this issue

waterfield88October 05, 2024 08:30PM

  Re: Was McVay premature in bailing on Goff to trade for Stafford?

sfbayram68October 06, 2024 03:07AM