McCarthy I'd take in the second, maybe.
I don't have faith in his processing speed or deep ball.
Ennis Rakestraw is a 5th rounder. Maybe 3rd if he tests really well. Could I be wrong? Sure. I'm usually pretty good with CBs and I've followed him for a few years.
I'm not on board with QB in the first ... but if the players were Bo Nix and Terrion Arnold I'd be fine.
McCarthy will be a good game manager and could develop deep ball consistency, but Im wary of QBs who can't take the top off because the D will shrink their field.