September 08, 2016 03:41AM
Admitting to another occasional guilty pleasure here. I tune into talent competitions like American's Got Talent from time to time. But one aspect of the show that really bugs me -- or any show that deals with magic acts? Calling something amazing and voting it through that clearly and obviously requires inside knowledge. Calling something amazing that requires that and presents no interesting sleight of hand tricks to go through process of elimination to uncover information. To trick people into divulging that info, etc. etc.

The Clairvoyants, a prime example, were on the other night:





Everything has to be pre-arranged with the judges for this to come off. The contestants don't go through any clever process that could uncover any of this. There is no "magic" involved, because it's 100% dependent on a set up.

To me, it's the same thing with card tricks that are obviously absolutely reliant on pre-arranged knowledge. Not skill. Not sleight of hand.

I have no idea why so many people are impressed by this -- and they made the finals.
SubjectAuthorViewsPosted

  Pet Peeve: There's "magic" and then there's magic.

Billy_T776September 08, 2016 03:41AM

  Re: Pet Peeve: There's "magic" and then there's magic.

~lyser542September 08, 2016 04:43AM

  Re: Pet Peeve: There's "magic" and then there's magic.

Billy_T486September 08, 2016 05:38AM

  Re: Pet Peeve: There's "magic" and then there's magic.

~lyser526September 08, 2016 06:05AM

  Re: Pet Peeve: There's "magic" and then there's magic.

Billy_T555September 08, 2016 07:09AM

  Re: Pet Peeve: There's "magic" and then there's magic.

~lyser512September 08, 2016 07:41AM

  I would be impressed..

sstrams502September 08, 2016 07:48AM

  Re: I would be impressed..

~lyser468September 08, 2016 10:15AM

  Good to see you, too, ~lyser!

sstrams518September 08, 2016 11:22AM

  Re: Pet Peeve: There's "magic" and then there's magic.

Billy_T492September 08, 2016 08:20AM

  Always good to see you

LesBaker529September 08, 2016 09:06AM

  Re: Always good to see you

~lyser499September 08, 2016 10:16AM

  Why yes I am

LesBaker507September 08, 2016 12:39PM

  Another angle on this: I call it the JJ Abrams effect.

Billy_T585September 08, 2016 08:31AM

  Re: Another angle on this: I call it the JJ Abrams effect.

~lyser576September 08, 2016 10:13AM

  Re: Thanks, Lyser

Billy_T513September 08, 2016 04:40PM

  Hmmm, well....

JamesJM536September 08, 2016 10:34AM

  Re: A belated redirection.

Billy_T509September 08, 2016 04:35PM