I take Creed Humphrey every single time. Wanted him before his marvelous rookie season, so this isn’t a hindsight statement.
However…
McVay compounded the error by holding back Atwell despite raving camp reports. To me that’s even more damning.
But McVay DID just publicly admit his mistake, so I’ve gotta give him that. Sigh…
It’s humbling when we are reminded that our heroes have feet of clay.