Quote
BearlyThere
Pretty interesting discussion on the Lions board. When you actually look at the list, there aren't a ton of guys that I'd rank above Goff. He fits in that middle tier of 10-19 range depending on how you feel.
Lions fans have Stafford everywhere from 5-16.
They are going to compile averages based on all the responses. Here is my QB ranking. Going into 2021 may look different with several guys retiring.
1. Patrick Mahomes
2. Aaron Rodgers
3. Tom Brady
4. Josh Allen (rising star)
5. Deshaun Watson
6. Drew Brees (falling fast)
7. Russell Wilson (sack machine)
8. Matthew Stafford
9. Justin Herbert (He may fall with more tape on him)
10. Jared Goff (total homer here but I've seen him do things none below can do.)
11. Ryan Tannehill
12. Baker Mayfield
14. Matt Ryan
16. Lamar Jackson (#1 Runner. Mediocre overall)
17. Kyler Murray (Overrated, especially if he can't run)
18. Derek Carr
19. Kirk Cousins
20. Ben Roethlisberger (falling fast)
21. Phillip Rivers (retired?)
22. Carson Wentz (broken?)
23. Dak Prescott (overrated)
24. Joe Burrow (Rising fast!)
25. Alex Smith
26. Sam Darnold (May be way underrated)
27. Jimmy Garappolo
28. Jalen Hurts (More tape may drop him)
29. Daniel Jones
30. Tua Tagovailoa
31. Drew Lock
32. Andy Dalton
33. Teddy Bridgewater
34. Gardner Minshew
35. Cam Newton
36. Mitch Trubisky
36. Nick Foles
37. Mike Glennon
#4 Allen and #9 Herbert too high might be one year wonders like Wentz, Watson has been better longer should be #4. Stafford about right but you are disrespecting Dak I would make him #9 and I would take him over all the non entering their 2nd year qb's beneath him. Of course I would take Herbert or Tua on rookie deal over him but that is a money+player decision not just an on the field one.
