Quote
max
Thats all fun and games with numbers. You want to point to a guy like Roethisberger. No one ever thought Ben was as bad as Goff, even when he had a few bad games.

All we have to do is open our eyes and see the issues with Goff.

And they ain't going away.

Honestly, you hold dark and negative opinions very close to your heart, and tend to magnify them. So what you are negatively affected by gains in significance. Goff played poorly in 3 out of 11 games this year, which is a lot, but is still not the black hole you want to make it out to be.

BR's 5th year was 2008. Since that was more than a decade ago, we'll count a bad game as a qb rating of 70 or less. In 2008 he had 5 of those, include one where he earned a 15.1. In those 5 games combined he had 1 TD, 10 INTs, and 4 fumbles. He got above a 52% completion percentage in only 1 of the 5.

Though what I asked was for you to name qbs who did not have multiple bad games in their 6th year.