Quote
moklerman
Is there any particular reason you chose these 6 QB's and left off the likes of Cam Newton(29), Derek Carr(27), Jimmy Garoppolo(27), Dak Prescott(25), Marcus Mariota(25), Mitchell Trubisky(24), Baker Mayfield(23)...alos, Russel Wilson is 30.
But I'll answer anyway.
Cam has been playing for 8 years, I cut it off at 7 or anyone drafted in 2012 who isn't 30 yet. Wilson turns 30 at the end of the month and was drafted in 2012. So is a borderline guy. Also, I don't care to evaluate Cam. I know what he is. His game has already peaked. All those other guys haven't shown me that they as good as the 6 I listed.
Be that as it may, here's my ranking:
1. Mahomes - This guy is a freak of nature. The sky is the limit for him.
2. Goff - He's an extension of McVay. Great combination of arm talent and brains.
3. Wilson - Super playmaker who is physically limited as a pocket passer. I've seen him fumble too much to put him higher.
4. Luck - Got it all and will be higher if he overcomes injuries. Just needs to play and get stronger.
5. Wentz - Not the same after the injury. Watched him throw a bad pick Sunday night and heard Collingsworth say Wentz had 7 picks dropped so far this year. Thats a problem.
6. Watson - He started slow this year. Picking it up now.
~ max ~
“The consciousness of good intentions disdains ambiguity.” - Alexander Hamilton
