but it is lacking at the playmaking positions. I don't really think they have guys that light up the scoreboard with long runs or long catches or long catch and runs. The quarterback while solid and much improved under Reid, is really just a good guy. (Probably not even a top 50% guy among starters)

I do think Reid is a Great Coach. I am different in evaluating coaches. To me, the most important thing of a Pro Coach is percentage of time making it to the playoffs.

That is consistent excitement for the home fans to always be in the hunt.

Hence, I have Reid ranked up there in the top 5 over the past 2 decades.