is it possible that he has actually had more good picks (gurley, donald, joyner, alexander, ogletre, brockers, jenkins, and johnson) than bad (robinson [maybe], barett jones ([4th rounder], quick, pead, givens [4th rounder]).

I didnt comment at all on the 2016 because its too early to tell. same thing goes for 2015 except for gurley as several players had a good 2015 season but poor 2016.

i think you could put mason, bailey and tj on both list as in general they each produced (relative to their draft position) on the field but had off the field issues. so i left them off.