According to the updated Rich Hill chart

The value we needed to add to our second round pick would be a 3rd in between our two picks. Our late 3 and a 5 would work. The league tends to value a pick next year as worth a pick a round later in the current year. If you willing to accept that, then this trade is fine if we advance to like the conference championship in the 24 playoffs. If out in the first or second round, then we overpaid by throwing in the 5th should be a 6th or nothing.