Quote
dzrams
Or you could say, "I don't care. Fisher didn't do as well as McVay would have or other coaches under the same or similar circumstances."
I.e. He didn't maximize the talent he DID have. This is of course what Demoff said after Fisher's termination.
McVay has never been under those particular circumstances.
In fact name examples of anyone who has and who did well.
I've asked that for years. No answer. A few attempts at an answer that did not hold up because the responder didn't account for everything I said.
And yes he maximized the talent he DID have. I would say that going 7-9 etc under those conditions is doing well considering.
Again...unless you can name others who did better under the specific conditions I named.
I grant that if you search long and hard you MIGHT find one rare exception. In theory. Maybe. I personally can't think of one.
My main beef with the Fisher discussions is that they ignore the context and conditions and act as if they didn't happen when in fact the particular condition I name is the single most important factor under discussion.
.
....
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 10/18/2017 05:45PM by zn.