I think the issue is Gaines

plays same position as SJD and he's pretty good at nose

so, IMO Gaines is out of position a A_Robs spot, but even so, he's a bit better--or maybe not--
call it a tie

But not sure SJD would be good there and then have Gaines at nose--his best spot

play they need is an upgrade at the A-Rob position, IMO,