Quote
oldschoolramfan
Sidelines "no catch" call by ref's, get's overturned by review, and is called a catch. WR's never really has control and then bobbles it out of his grasp.
Personally, I thought he made a "football move" with the ball securely pinned against his chest. Then he fumbled it out of bounds. So I thought the replay did its job there. And, to be sure, imagine how which people arguing for which results would have instantly flipped if the ball stayed in-bounds and was recovered by Green Bay.
The problem with the second catch/no-catch was that McCarthy didn't challenge it.