I don't understand the detractors on this board. If it is someone like Kendricks where his problems smack you in the face fine. But being able to pick up on a player being bad watching the game in real-time is extremely difficult. I watch games in slow motion after watching them live. And I am still pausing, rewinding multiple times when evaluating players.
I'm at the point where when I read negative/positive opinions from most people I just assume it is a mostly emotional reaction. Sorry for the rant.