Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: Do we make the playoffs without him?

March 13, 2018 05:41AM
Quote
RockRam
It cost the Rams a 2nd and EJ Gaines to rent Sammy for 1 year. That's expensive.
Now the Rams will no doubt get a 3rd rounder back as a comp pick. So that helps a lot.
But, equally no doubt this is not the way Les Snead pictured this going.

All that said: it is very hard to turn around a perennial losing team. If someone were to say to you: For EJ Gaines and a forfeiture of a 2nd round pick, I'll give you an 11 win year and a home playoff game, would you have done it? My answer would have been: "In a heartbeat".

Essentially that's what the Rams did. Sammy had a lot to do with the Rams turning things around. Nobody has denied that.
So I'm going to choose to look at it that way.....and move on.

After Sneads FA acquisitions and draft last year, the hiring of McVay and Phillips, and the acquisition pre-FA of Peters and Talib, to get all upset with him over Watkins being offered crazy dollars to go the Chiefs and refusing to match that price, Snead gets a mulligan from me. Nobody bats 1.000 because they don't control every aspect of a situation.

Getting a 3rd round comp. pick somewhat minimizes the failure to sign him long term because when Snead made the trade, he said that the comp. pick was part of the equation for why he pulled the trigger.

It was a calculated risk. Snead pictured this scenario when the trade happened because he talked about this scenario publically.

Here's the calculation of worst case scenario: you pay a 2nd, get back a 3rd, and you get to rent the guy for one year, which helps build the profile of your team, it helps get you to the playoffs for the first time in 15 years.

I would argue that's worth it.

I suspect we likely wouldn't have made the playoffs without him.
SubjectAuthorViewsPosted

  Was the one year rental on Sammy worth it?

RockRam248March 13, 2018 03:50AM

  No. Nm

jemach103March 13, 2018 04:00AM

  Re: Yes.

spagsbacker149March 13, 2018 04:03AM

  Yes, it was. Without him 9-7, maybe (NM)

Steve87March 13, 2018 04:21AM

  Re: I'll vote yes

leafnose81March 13, 2018 05:11AM

  Re: Do we make the playoffs without him?

dzrams79March 13, 2018 05:41AM

  Calculated for "X"

leafnose80March 13, 2018 06:05AM

  20% of his catches were TDs, 28% of rec TDs were Sammy's

JoeMad100March 13, 2018 05:56AM

  Would Rams be 11-5 last year without him?

stlramz85March 13, 2018 06:00AM