Only thing that hurts Kurt is health and longevity

The donut hole was he wasn't healthy. Because he got a late start in his career and was limited 5 year because of health, that hurts long term look, but he was at such a high level for

1999-2001

and

2007-2009


He had 5 seasons with QB ratings in the 90's or above and 2 seasons with a QB rating over 100.

with the 3 superbowl appearances and MVP. Plus, the incredible story, I put him #2 in the list this year only behind Bruce.