perhaps you should review your rules of scientific inquiry.

no one said any of those qbs are HOFs (although i think many would argue that mcnair was pretty darn good). however, if each of them produced their best or near best performance under the tutelage of a single coach, does that not provide evidence (not conclusive of course but evidence nonetheless) that said coach was able to get the most out the skills of any individual qb no matter how pedestrian the qb is?

and btw,,,before last night some people here were talking about the emergence of SB as a legit star in the nfl.

Quote
govane

Quote
PHDram
I thought I'd use the Fisher hater tactics.

That's funny right der.

What's funnier is that someone would use Sam Bradford, Vince Young, Case Keenum, Kerry Collins, Neil O'Donnell and Billy Volek as evidence that a coach is good at developing QB's.


GO FISHER!