Glock 43.

Despite my having big hands (mostly fingers), I love how much grip I could get on it. My hands basically swallow it. It's only 6+1, but you can buy extended clips for pretty cheap. It's basically the same size as a 26, but it's a little lighter and smaller clip. And I actually like the lighter weight.

For me and the situation I'd be using it, smaller is better. If one wanted to hunt, obviously I'd go with the 19.

I shot a friend's 27 a couple of years ago. Not sure I'd get something that big in a subcompact gun lol. I guess if I'm shooting Bigfoot stuck in the mud at 5 yards, I might be OK.