the OP said "Goff has no upside" which is a definitive statement with no wiggle room. he didnt speak about probability or likelihood. he emphatically denied the possibility of any upside which was my issue. imo thats not perfectly reasonable.
huh? reserving judgement until the end of the season is not a palatable option for you? i dont get your point.
No one denied the possibility. Questioning how likely it might be is perfectly reasonable.
And it isn't a contradiction because I am not suggesting Goff should be putting up the ridiculous numbers he reached at one point in '18. But being successful and being elite are two different things. Goff should be a lot more successful with what he's got to work with. I think it's very fair to say that he's underacheiving.
As far as contradictions, how can you have a bottom line of wait and see? That's literally NOT having a bottom line.[/quote]
