Quote
zn
Quote
moklerman
Well, that's not true now, is it? Unless you're saying that Warner and Green are physically identical. Which they aren't. Green's 6'3" and Warner's 6'2". An inch different on where the knee was hit would make a difference, don't you think?
Knees. DB throwing himself at knees. Helpless qb who can't see it coming, an open target, Harrison takes a run and jump and throws himself at the knees.
You know sometimes arguing about everything takes one past the outer boundaries of the plausible.
And I;m done.
.
Green did get injured. It was a perfect storm for him. But it's a bit of a leap in logic for you to argue that Warner would have definitely been injured too. Maybe? Sure. But you're saying the he definitely would have and that isn't reasonable. QB's get hit on their lower legs all the time and don't get injured so I'm not sure why you're trying to state it as fact that Warner would have been lost to the same injury Green got.
And that's just the physical side of things. How many other variables are there to consider? Would Faulk have done the exact same thing? Would Harrison? Would Warner have reacted differently? Got rid of it more quickly? Scrambled? Ducked?
Quote
ZN
You know sometimes arguing about everything takes one past the outer boundaries of the plausible.
Then why are you doing that?