Quote
RockRam
Keenum is like Fitzpatrick: marginal starters/good back-ups
I disagree. Not with the fact you put them both in that category.
(Not that you had to go out of your way to do that...there is absolutely no one who would disagree and call Keenum an NFL starter caliber qb.)
What I disagree with is that Fitz is at the same level OF THAT as Keenum.
No he's not. Keenum's actual best attributes---his intangibles, his instincts, his game sense---far outstrip Fitz.
Anyway that aside.
What I find frustrating about this discussion is the number of times this logic repeats. --->
POSTER A: Keenum has limitations and he's just a #2 caliber qb. But he has attributes that make him a good version of that.
POSTER B: Not true. Keenum has limitations. He's just a #2 caliber qb
POSTER A: Sigh.
